The Real Cost of AI May Be Outside Your Business Case
When customers, suppliers and competitors adopt the same technology, the economics of your investment can change before you’ve realized the return.
By Paula Fontana · November 10, 2026
Most organizations evaluate AI investments by looking inward. They estimate the time employees will save, the processes they can automate, the costs they can reduce and the productivity they expect to gain.
Those calculations matter, but they assume something important: that the economics surrounding the business will remain relatively stable while the investment delivers its return.
AI challenges that assumption.
In Episode 2 of Uncharted, Deniz Tudor and I explored what happens when the organizations on both sides of a transaction adopt AI, and why the value of an investment may depend as much on what others do with the technology as what you do with it.
Your ecosystem is investing too
At a recent gathering of private company directors, I heard an example that has stayed with me.
The discussion centered on Blue Cross Blue Shield and the use of AI in healthcare claims processing. While insurers were adopting AI to improve processing efficiency, healthcare providers were using the same technology to prepare and submit claims. The example illustrated how changes in provider behavior and claims costs could offset some of the operational savings an insurer expected to achieve.
Each side had a rational reason to invest. Each expected to improve its own economics. But the actions of one changed the outcomes available to the other.
That dynamic extends well beyond healthcare.
If customers use AI to compare products, negotiate prices and switch providers more easily, the economics of customer acquisition and retention change. If suppliers use AI to improve their own margins, the benefits may not flow equally to their customers. If competitors automate the same activities, an early cost advantage may quickly become the minimum required to compete.
The return on an AI investment increasingly depends on how the surrounding market responds.
When efficiency becomes the price of admission
Technology has always changed competitive dynamics. What makes AI particularly interesting is how widely the same underlying capabilities can be applied.
An organization might achieve a meaningful productivity improvement through automation. For a period, that advantage may translate into better margins, lower prices or greater capacity.
But what happens when every competitor can access similar capabilities?
The gain may remain operationally valuable while losing much of its competitive significance. Customers may come to expect faster service or lower prices. Competitors may pass savings into the market. The productivity improvement becomes part of the industry’s new cost structure.
This creates an important distinction between capturing an efficiency gain and creating a lasting competitive advantage.
Both can justify investment, but they have different implications for strategy and valuation.
The more accessible a technology becomes, the more important it is to understand what makes an organization’s application of that technology distinctive. Proprietary knowledge, customer relationships, distribution, data, execution and the ability to redesign an entire business model may ultimately matter more than access to the technology itself.
The business case needs a wider lens
Deniz raised a related concern during our conversation: organizations investing in AI because they feel they should, without first defining the business problem they intend to solve.
That creates a measurement problem. An organization can demonstrate that people are using AI, that activities are happening faster or that a process costs less, without establishing whether the investment has improved its competitive or commercial position.
Even a well-defined business problem is only part of the equation.
Leaders also need to consider what will happen as the same capabilities spread through their market. Who captures the economic benefit? How much of the gain can the organization retain? Which assumptions about pricing, demand, customer behavior and competitive differentiation are likely to change?
These considerations become particularly important when the investment involves a new product, a change in operating model or a substantial commitment of capital.
A business case based entirely on internal productivity may miss the largest changes taking place around the business.
The opportunity is bigger than the efficiency
There is another side to this dynamic.
If AI changes the economics of an industry, organizations have opportunities to reconsider how value is created, delivered and captured.
Lower costs may make previously uneconomic customer segments attractive. New capabilities may allow companies to offer services they could not previously deliver. Changes in how customers evaluate and purchase products may create openings for entirely different business models.
These opportunities require a different starting point from traditional automation initiatives. Rather than asking where AI can make the existing business more efficient, leaders can ask what becomes commercially possible as the technology changes the economics of the market.
That is a question about strategy, market development and growth.
The return depends on what happens around you
AI investment decisions will continue to require financial discipline. Organizations need clear objectives, credible assumptions and evidence that investments are delivering value.
But those assumptions need to account for a market in motion.
The most useful business cases will consider how customers, suppliers and competitors are likely to change their behavior, how quickly anticipated advantages might erode, and where new opportunities to capture value could emerge.
An investment can deliver exactly the productivity gains it promised and still produce a very different commercial outcome than expected.
The question is increasingly who captures the value when everyone becomes more capable.
This article extends a discussion from Episode 2 of Uncharted: We Spent It All on the Conference, with Paula Fontana and Deniz Tudor.